EXCLUSIVE: VC expenses laid bare
The head of the University of Leeds has spent thousands of pounds of University money on staying in five-star hotels, traveling across the globe, and dining in some of the world’s most high-end restaurants, exclusive information has revealed.
The Vice-Chancellor (VC) Michael Arthur has racked up just under £42,000 of expenses over the past three years, a bill picked up by University finances and partly funded by students’ tuition fees.
Professor Arthur’s expenses are not easily available to the public and it took a Freedom of Information request before such details were disclosed to Leeds Student.
The expenses report shows that the VC has spent thousands of pounds over the course of three years staying in luxury hotels whilst on business trips. Several of the hotels cost hundreds of pounds a night, including the five-star Sofitel St James hotel which cost the University £727.88 for the Vice-Chancellor’s two night stay in the heritage grade II listed building in London.
On another occasion, £265.38 was paid for Professor Arthur to spend a night at The Chesterfield Mayfair Hotel whilst attending a meeting with the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills. The hotel’s website describes itself as a place where guests can ‘live like royalty.’
Leeds Student has also discovered that the Vice-Chancellor lives in a rent-free flat paid for by the University. The free accommodation is part of the Vice-Chancellor’s benefits which also include free healthcare and altogether total £7,000 per year. This is on top of an annual salary of £253,000.
In the 2009/10 financial year the VC also received £59,000 in ‘employer contributions to defined benefit scheme’.
Professor Arthur has repeatedly claimed that he earns less than the Prime Minister yet according to parliament.uk the Prime Minister earns a basic salary of £142,500 – £110,500 less than our Vice-Chancellor. Even when the Prime Minister’s additional MP salary of £65,738 is added to this, the total still comes to less than the VC’s basic salary.
A University spokesperson said that the Vice-Chancellor donates £5,000 of his personal money each year to the Annual Alumni Fund.
The VC travelled frequently between 2007-10 visiting Hong Kong, New York, Sydney, Toronto and Amsterdam, amongst other major cities across the world. A University spokesperson said that forging closer relations with alumni is an important part of the VC’s role, which entails “regular travel around the UK and increasingly overseas”, with costs incurred through “business-related entertainment and accommodation”.
The spokesperson added: “[The VC] has personally spearheaded a campaign to raise £60m in donations for the University over the next five years.” However, in a time of economising and budget cuts, the spokesperson could not explain why such trips could not be prevented with video conferencing.
Although the expenses’ report lists only two flights being paid for by the University, a full account was given for other forms of travel. In one month alone the VC spent £562.09 on taxis in the UK, USA and Australia in April 2009. A further £167 was spent on a National Express train journey in February 2009. The University would not confirm whether the VC travels by first class however.
Professor Arthur also frequently claims expenses on ‘refreshments’ whilst travelling by train. The sum of £3.50 for refreshments was claimed back by the VC during a National Express train trip he took between meetings on 25 April 2008. The University would not explain why the VC could not have paid for this sum with his own money.
Travelling across the globe, the VC has also eaten with potential donors at some of the most exclusive restaurants in the world, all paid for with University’s expenses. £390 was spent on a meal at the illustrious Cirque Restaurant in which all men are required to wear dinner jackets, on October 2008.
Closer to home, accounts show the VC repeatedly wining and dining multi-millionaires at the Leeds restaurant Anthonys, the high end Brasserie Forty 4, and Raymond Blanc’s Brasserie Blanc. A University spokesperson said: “The Vice-Chancellor’s personal standing is critical to donors’ willingness to support the University. So far donors have contributed £14m, demonstrating their confidence in the University’s leadership and ambition.”
When told of Leeds Student’s findings Leeds University Union’s Communications and Internal Affairs Officer (CIA), Rachel Wenstone, said: “Our main concern about University funding is, and remains, quality for students.
We know that nationally, many students are not happy with the quality of education being received for the fees they are paying. The cost of gaining a degree is already a huge burden, so it is essential that we are told how every penny of our money is being spent. This is the only way that the University can be held to account.
In the coming weeks, when the new tuition fee levels are set, it will be more important than ever that University finances are completely transparent. Potential applicants must be allowed to make informed decisions on where to study based on how their money will be spent.”
A University spokesperson said: “The Vice-Chancellor’s chairmanship of the Russell Group has coincided with the biggest upheaval in higher education for decades. He has consistently made the case publicly and privately that universities like Leeds must be properly funded despite cuts to public spending if they are to continue to deliver first-class learning and teaching for students.”
UPDATE: The University has asked that Leeds Student publishes its full response to our questions. Please see the University’s full statement below.
“The University of Leeds is a complex and increasingly international organisation with an ambition to secure a place among the world’s top 50 universities by 2015.
Forging closer relations with alumni is an important part of the Vice-Chancellor’s role and he personally spearheads the Campaign to raise £60m through donations over the next five years. This entails regular travel around the UK and increasingly overseas, and costs are incurred through business-related entertainment and accommodation.
The Vice-Chancellor also chairs the Russell Group and has previously held roles directly related to his work at Leeds with the World Universities Network, and the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority. Again, these roles require travel and overnight stays.
The Vice-Chancellor’s personal standing is critical to donors’ willingness to support the University. So far donors have contributed £14m, demonstrating their confidence in the University’s leadership and ambition. Of the £14m, £11m was donated specifically for student-centred projects, including the construction of the Marjorie and Arnold Ziff Building, which houses the Student Services Centre; and the Stanley and Audrey Burton Gallery.
More than £1m has been raised through the Annual Alumni Fund and already invested in students. The money has been spent on scholarships to enable students who wouldn’t otherwise have been able to come to Leeds to do so and on schemes including Leeds for Life, buying more books for the library, improvements to campus facilities and a student hardship fund. It also supports volunteering work, which enables students to devote more of their time to worthy projects in the community rather than to part-time jobs. Our alumni also act as mentors to current students, helping establish internship opportunities and placements. The Vice-Chancellor himself donates £5,000 each year to the Annual Alumni Fund.
The Vice-Chancellor’s chairmanship of the Russell Group has coincided with the biggest upheaval in higher education for decades. He has consistently made the case publicly and privately that universities like Leeds must be properly funded despite cuts to public spending if they are to continue to deliver first-class learning and teaching for students.
The University initiated an economies exercise in October 2009 to make savings in preparation of cuts to funding, and – particularly given the current financial climate – every effort is made to avoid any profligacy. In 2009/10, the total amount reclaimed by the Vice-Chancellor or spent by the Vice-Chancellor on his University credit card was £14,000, which is relatively modest given his commitment to the Campaign and other external roles.
- The Vice-Chancellor’s current salary package places him 24th in the UK*, after leaders of other universities, including Leeds Metropolitan University, Northumbria University and the University of Bristol.
- The Vice-Chancellor’s salary is £253k. He and other members of the senior management team voluntarily chose not to take a pay rise in 2009 or 2010.
- The Vice-Chancellor is a member of the Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS) and his pension contributions are paid at the same rate as for other academic and related staff. In 2009/10, the University contributed £59k. He also receives healthcare benefits provided by the University, which cost £918 in 2009/10. The total value of benefits in kind, including accommodation and healthcare, was assessed for tax purposes in 2009/10 was £7k.
- A rent-free flat is provided for the Vice-Chancellor’s use, as is customary for many other universities and similar institutions. The flat is also used for official University business such as meeting alumni and funders. The Vice-Chancellor pays his own bills including Council Tax and utilities.
*Table of Vice-Chancellors’ salaries for 2008-9, published by the THE in April 2010.”